Fall The Fearless Girl

Marshall McLuhan called advertising corporate art. While he’s not wrong, I think his early views of advertising were based in an era where the ad remained a promotion of a product. Products in most ads these days are at least second to brand narrative.1 Enter the Fearless Girl, an abhorrent piece of corporate propaganda which has taken the concept of advertising to an entirely new level of cynicism.

Cara Sheffler did a great job pointing out why the work is an insult to feminism, not a promotion of it. Things being equal between the sexes and all, it’s also pretty bad at a societal level.

What the statue represents is submission to the idea the fight against power exists only within the confines the powerful approve of. This idea originated in a board room and was approved in one. ‘Fearless Girl’ has a presumed acceptance of capitalism; that we may stand up to the market so long as we remain in sight of it.

With ‘Fearless Girl’ now set to remain in the Financial District, we’re witnessing what the next generation of billboards will look like: corporate art in the public space, promoting a subtle dialogue of complicity not to any inspired place of imagination, but rather financial allegiance.2

      Footnotes
  • This isn’t surprising, especially as millennials start coming in to money. The way Urban Outfitters went from selling t-shirts to an entire lifestyle, advertising will continue that tradition of the projected idea behind a brand—and how that will improve your life—put the work of a social media influencer in front of it, and reap the benefits.
  • I believe McLuhan is wrong when he calls advertising an art, even a corporate art, at this level. Allegiance to an idea is never the goal of a piece of art; generally that is the opposite of what artists work for. Constructing a narrative in order to control the outcome is not art, even if a few pieces of that process along the way are aesthetically appealing.

March 28, 2017 at 10:05 am

Blog · Commentary

· ·

Union Square

New York City

New York

Hot Dog Vendor II

America

New York City

September 5, 2015 at 2:09 pm

About America · Photography

· · ·

Between The Lines

America

Manhattan

September 3, 2015 at 10:12 pm

About America · Photography

· · ·

Snow Falling In SoHo

Snow

January 4, 2015 at 11:44 am

Blog

· ·

Midtown Rain

Midtown

Wandering Midtown with Sarah

Andi (Waiting For The Train)

Andi

Abandoned Phone Booth

Phone Booth

Somewhere in Brooklyn

January 3, 2015 at 11:50 am

Blog

· · ·

Sarah (At The Leica Gallery)

Sarah

Sarah Symmonds

Lies (NYC Walls)

Lies

January 2, 2015 at 7:41 pm

Blog

· · · ·

Hello 2015

kill

At the Museum of Modern Art, New York.

January 1, 2015 at 1:01 pm

Blog

· · ·

NYC, NYE

Midtown

December 31, 2014 at 10:33 pm

Blog

· · · ·

Cross Walk / Class Divide

Capitalism

Subway Arrival

America

Manhattan

October 16, 2014 at 6:39 pm

About America · Photography

· ·

Coffee With Hayes

America

Manhattan